Nazuk Jain

Believe Product Managers Stay Sharp All Day? Not Quite.

Nazuk Jain -

I still remember the day. It was late afternoon, and a team member pinged me on Slack with a question, but my response cost my team hours of extra work. It wasn’t a complex choice—just prioritizing a bug fix over a small feature enhancement. But my mind, drained from back-to-back meetings and decisions all day, failed to consider the downstream impact. After a good night’s rest the next morning, I saw the mistake and corrected the course.

Does this also sound familiar to you? As Product Managers, we pride ourselves on being sharp decision-makers, capable of juggling 100+ choices daily. But here’s the truth no one talks about: we’re not built to stay sharp all day.

By 3PM, decision fatigue creeps in, turning even simple choices into mental mountains. It’s not laziness or lack of skill—it’s biology! It's science! Our brains have a finite capacity for high-level decision-making, and once we exhaust it, the quality of our judgment suffers.

But here’s the good news: you can manage your decision-making energy.

Here are four strategies that can help:

1️⃣ Stack Rank Decisions
Not all decisions are created equal. High-impact decisions need your sharpest thinking, so tackle these early in the day when your mind is freshest.

Tip: Start your morning by listing out decisions for the day. Label them as high, medium, or low impact, and focus on the high-impact ones first. For example, prioritize key stakeholder meetings or feature discussions over low-stakes emails or approvals.

Here is an example structure:

Tier 1: Strategic Decisions (Mornings 8-12pm)

  • Product vision and roadmap
  • Major feature prioritization
  • Resource allocation
  • Strategic partnerships
  • Architecture changes

Tier 2: Tactical Decisions (Afternoons 12-2pm)

  • Sprint planning
  • Design reviews
  • Stakeholder management
  • Feature specifications

Tier 3: Operational Decisions (late afternoons generally reserved 2-5 PMs)

  • Daily standups
  • Routine communications
  • Minor bug triage
  • Regular status updates

2️⃣ Systematize Routine Choices
Every small decision drains your mental energy. Simplify or automate low-stakes choices to save bandwidth for what truly matters.

Tip: Use templates or predefined rules for common decisions. For instance, use a framework for feature prioritization—like scoring based on impact and effort—so you’re not starting from scratch every time.

3️⃣ Respect Your Energy Cycles
Recognize when you’re at your peak and plan critical thinking tasks during that time. Mornings are usually best for deep work, while afternoons are better for routine tasks.

Tip: Block out your calendar for deep work in the morning as mentioned in bullet #1. Use this time for strategic tasks, like roadmap planning or aligning with leadership. Save less demanding tasks, like feedback or email reviews, for the afternoon.

4️⃣ Take Recovery Breaks
Decision fatigue is like physical fatigue—it requires rest to recover. Short breaks can help you reset and recharge.

Tip: Schedule 5-10 minute breaks every couple of hours. Step away from your desk, stretch, or take a quick walk. Even a few deep breaths can work wonders. Studies show that a 9-minute stretch can ease mental fatigue and create the needed oxytocin.

🎯 Understanding your energy cycles isn’t a weakness; it’s a superpower. When you align your decisions with your natural rhythms, you perform at your best.

Here are a few of the protocols I follow to keep performing at my best

1. Decision Automation Protocol

  • Create templates for common feature specs
  • Set up auto-routing for routine requests
  • Establish clear escalation paths
  • Document decision criteria for team reference

2. Meeting Strategy

  • No decisions in meetings after 3 PM
  • Mandatory pre-reads for all decision meetings
  • 24-hour rule for major decisions
  • Decision-free Fridays for deep work

3. Energy Management

  • Block 90-minute deep work sessions
  • Use the 2-minute rule: If it takes less than 2 minutes, do it now
  • Delegate decisions to the lowest appropriate level
  • Build decision buffers between high-stakes meetings

Your Action Plan

This Week:

  1. Audit your decisions for one day
  2. Identify your high-energy hours
  3. Create one decision framework
  4. Set up three automated responses

This Month:

  1. Restructure your calendar around decision types
  2. Document your most common decisions
  3. Train your team on your frameworks
  4. Establish no-decision time blocks
As a Product Manager, your decision quality directly impacts your product's success. Treat your decision-making capacity like the finite resource it is. You're not just managing a product—you're managing your cognitive resources.
Remember: The best PMs aren't the ones making the most decisions. They're the ones making the right decisions at the right time with the right energy.

Thats all!

Nazuk

Next Week: How Top PMs Use AI to Automate 50% of Their Decisions

Want to level up your decision-making game? Subscribe to my newsletter at Nazukjain.com to elevate your leadership game.

P.S. If you are an early career PM check out the Upskill PM fundamentals course that will equip you with strategies needed to perform at your best. Currently on 50% off Sale only for Black Friday!